Connect with us

Mississippi Today

Gov. Tate Reeves’ brother used backchannel to state auditor to help clean up Brett Favre welfare mess

Published

on

Gov. Tate Reeves’ brother coordinated with state Auditor Shad White on damage control for former NFL star Brett Favre after an audit first revealed in 2020 that the athlete had received more than $1 million in welfare funds, according to text messages the governor’s political campaign released Thursday.

Todd Reeves, Favre’s friend, had also arranged conversations in early 2020 with Gov. Reeves so that Favre could ask for the governor’s help in funding the University of Southern Mississippi volleyball stadium, one of the centerpieces of the ongoing welfare scandal.

The texts released Thursday show how, on Favre’s behalf, Todd Reeves facilitated the athlete’s repayment of some of the funds and asked for White to make a public statement that “the investigation (shows to this point) Brett has done nothing wrong.”

Meanwhile, attorneys for the state auditor’s office and the attorney general’s office have fought for eight months to withhold these texts from Mississippi Today, who originally requested them. The state argued as recently as Wednesday the texts are part of their investigative file in the welfare case, and publicly releasing them could harm the ongoing welfare scandal investigation.

But on Thursday, as Mississippi Today prepared its story about the withheld records, the Reeves campaign released what they say are the text messages in question.

After Mississippi Today reached out to Todd Reeves and Gov. Reeves’ campaign for comment about the texts and the state’s argument that they are evidence in an ongoing investigation, the Reeves campaign did not respond to the inquiry but instead sent out a media release chastising the news organization for covering the story. Todd Reeves also gave his own quote for the campaign’s release.

“I’ve been friendly with Brett for years, and always heard great things about Shad,” Todd Reeves said in a press release Thursday, distributed by his brother’s gubernatorial campaign. “I didn’t learn anything about this TANF mess or Brett’s dealings with the state until it was front page news. When Brett was considering repaying the funds, he asked me if I could help him get in touch with the auditor to coordinate that–so that’s what I did. I helped money get back in the right hands, not the wrong hands, and I think that’s what most people would have done. Brett believed he had done nothing wrong, and I helped convince him to return the money anyway. Those are the texts in question. I know Mississippi Today is willing to lie about us, so I just wanted to get the truth out.”

Mississippi Today cannot verify if the Reeves campaign released all of the texts sought by the litigation because the news outlet has not been allowed to view the requested records. The Reeves campaign did not respond to follow-up questions about the completeness of the records they released on Thursday, and the attorney general’s office declined to comment.

The news organization first filed a public records request for texts between White and Todd Reeves in December 2022. Additionally, the request also included any of White’s messages or emails that made reference to Todd Reeves. Mississippi Today was denied the records and filed suit against the auditor’s office in January 2023.

Hinds County Chancery Court Judge Crystal Wise Martin reviewed the texts in private, on Mississippi Today’s request, to determine if the documents were, in fact, exempt from public release.

“They obviously relate to the DHS investigation,” Judge Martin said during a hearing Wednesday, after she had seen the records. “There’s no question about that.”

Special Assistant Attorney General Rex Shannon, representing the auditor’s office for the state, argued against releasing the texts on Wednesday, saying:

  • “Their disclosure may harm that investigation by chilling similar communications in the future.”
  • “The records in question reveal and confirm the identity of a potential witness.”
  • “The records in question would potentially disclose investigatory techniques and or the results of those techniques.”
  • “The records in question, if publicly produced, would potentially impede or jeopardize any prosecution of certain individuals that may result from the DHS investigation.”

White has said several times previously that he has turned over all welfare investigation-related material in his possession to the FBI. While the Mississippi Department of Human Services has sued Favre in its ongoing civil case, overseen by Gov. Reeves, Favre has not faced any criminal charges.

READ MORE: What exactly is Gov. Tate Reeves’ involvement in the welfare scandal?

In the early days of Gov. Reeves’ current term, Favre used Todd Reeves as a way to communicate with the governor. Favre, who endorsed Gov. Reeves in his election months earlier, was hoping the governor would help him find public funding to pay for the completed construction of a volleyball stadium at University of Southern Mississippi. Favre had made a guarantee to the university. If he didn’t find the funding somewhere, Favre would have to pay out of his own pocket. According to texts previously released, Todd Reeves would facilitate lines of communication for the athlete.

“Brett, you aren’t bothering me at all and please always feel free to reach out to me anytime,” Todd Reeves texted Favre, according to a previously released text Favre forwarded to Gov. Phil Bryant on Jan. 26, 2020. “I will help any way I can. I will be glad to set something up with Tate. Tell me kind of what the plan in place for funding is/was. Did Gov Bryant mention maybe trying to get it as part of a bond bill for the University?”

At this time, the USM project had already received at least $5 million in funding from the federal Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program, which is supposed to provide monthly cash assistance to very poor families, through a nonprofit run by Nancy New.

Within days and weeks of Favre’s communication with the Reeves brothers in early 2020, the auditor would arrest the two top welfare officials who had been working with Favre and the volleyball project would be outed as part of a sprawling scheme to misuse tens of millions of welfare funds.

White had taken a strong stance against the widespread corruption at MDHS leading up to the May 2020 release of his annual audit, which questioned almost $100 million worth of spending.

But in a press conference describing some of the more egregious findings, White did not draw attention to Favre, whose welfare payment, listed under Favre Enterprises, was tucked in a bullet list on page 18 of the 104-page report. Still, the revelation made national news.

Two days later, Favre repaid $500,000 of the $1.1 million and promised the auditor he would return the additional $600,000 in installments in the coming months. First, the texts show, White sent Todd Reeves the address of where to send the money, then they arranged for an agent to pick up a check at the office of Favre’s agent.

“If possible, Brett would like you to say something along the lines of “the investigation (shows to this point) Brett has done nothing wrong and the monies he is paying back for commercials and Psa’s is from his own good will,” Todd Reeves texted White on May 6, 2020.

White praised Favre in the statement he released the same day: “I want to applaud Mr. Favre for his good faith effort to make this right and make the taxpayers and TANF families whole. To date, we have seen no records indicating Mr. Favre knew that TANF was the program that served as the source of the money he was paid.”

A few weeks later, Todd Reeves texted White, “Just wanted to tell you I appreciate you talking and helping the last couple of weeks.”

The last text Todd Reeves produced Thursday was a message he sent the auditor in September of 2020.

“I think Brett is working to get some more money sent in,” Todd Reeves said. “He’s had some reporters start hounding them again. I’m sure they have contacted your office. He’s just asking not to be thrown under the bus as he is working within the timeline.”

But Favre did not return the remainder of the funds until White issued him an official demand more than a year later in October 2021. By that time, the auditor said Favre also owed $228,000 in interest.

Mississippi Today’s December 2022 records request to the auditor’s office asked for text messages and emails to examine how Todd Reeves, potentially on Favre’s behalf, may have communicated with White during this time period.

“We’re here arguing about the records that belong to the people of the state of Mississippi,” Henry Laird, Mississippi Today’s attorney, told the judge on Wednesday. “These are not the auditor’s records. These are Mississippi’s records. And unless there is an exemption that allows the auditor to say they shouldn’t be produced, they should be produced.”

Judge Martin did not rule whether to release the texts Wednesday. On Thursday, as she continued to decide how to rule and before Mississippi Today published its story about the hearing, the Reeves campaign chose to publicly release texts between Todd Reeves and White.

“While Mr. Reeves has the right to release his text messages, the State Auditor’s Office has not and will not release information regarding a potential or ongoing investigation to protect the integrity of an investigation,” Fletcher Freeman, a spokesperson for the auditor’s office, said in a statement Thursday. “The men and women of the State Auditor’s Office have worked tirelessly to hold those who steal taxpayer’s dollars accountable, and we will continue to work with prosecutors and our federal partners to do so.”

Acknowledging that the texts might not, on their face, appear to be part of an investigative file, Shannon, the state attorney, provided the judge in Wednesday’s hearing with auditor’s office press releases that relate to the content in the texts. Those included a release in May of 2020 about Favre repaying some of the $1.1 million in TANF funds he received; a release in October of 2021 about the auditor demanding the repayment of TANF funds from several people, including Favre for the remaining funds White said he owed; and a release about several guilty pleas in the case.

Mississippi Today’s records request asked for messages sent between Feb. 1, 2020, and June 1, 2020. In this timeframe, White made initial arrests in the welfare fraud case (Feb. 5), Mississippi Today published a story first uncovering that welfare funds had been used to build the volleyball stadium (Feb. 27), and White released his annual audit (May 4), which first revealed the direct welfare payment to Favre. The records request also asked for messages sent between Sept. 1, 2021 and Dec. 31, 2021. In this timeframe, the welfare agency released its commissioned forensic audit, which provided more details about the misspending and prompted White to issue the official demand for repayment from Favre.

In response to a separate request to Gov. Reeves for his texts with Favre prior to becoming governor in 2020, the governor’s office said it was not “in possession or control of any public records responsive to your request.” Before 2020, Reeves served as lieutenant governor in the Mississippi Senate. Generally speaking, lawmakers have used the legislative exemption in the Public Records Act to withhold records from reporters.

Asked about the volleyball stadium at Neshoba County Fair in the summer of 2022, Reeves suggested he didn’t support the idea of using any taxpayer funds to build sports facilities.

“Look I don’t know all the details as to how that came about,” he said. “What I do know is that it doesn’t seem like an expense that I would personally support for TANF dollars. I don’t even like the state building stadiums with general tax dollars.”

However, Favre and Bryant seemed confident Tate Reeves would help.

On election day in November 2019, Favre texted then-Gov. Bryant, “I know it’s Election Day and you are probably busy but while we know who our Governor is presently not to mention arguably the most popular and influential I want to stay on your radar. If our guy wins I’ll feel better about things but if the other guy wins I feel like Nancy and I can forget our vision for Southern Miss.”

“That’s one reason I have been pushing Tate so hard,” Bryant responded. “He has to win. Then we set up a meeting on Wellness Center at USM.”

Gov. Reeves did win, and in late January of 2020, Todd Reeves set up a phone call for Favre and the governor to discuss funding. About a week later, as White was preparing to make arrests, Favre expressed his desire to take Gov. Reeves to see the volleyball stadium, texting, “and it would only be us. I want you to see what your (sic) trying to help me for.”

It’s unclear if Gov. Reeves actually pushed to include funding for the facility in a legislative or other kind of appropriation, but his brother certainly gave Favre the impression that he would.

“I think the angle Tate is looking at is a bond bill according to Todd his brother,” Favre texted Bryant on Feb. 7, 2020, as the fallout from the arrests was still materializing.

READ MOREGov. Tate Reeves inspired welfare payment targeted in civil suit, texts show

This article first appeared on Mississippi Today and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

Mississippi Today

Memorial Health System takes over Biloxi hospital, what will change?

Published

on

mississippitoday.org – Roy Howard Community Journalism Center – 2025-02-21 15:22:00

by Justin Glowacki  with contributions from Rasheed Ambrose, Javion Henry, McKenna Klamm, Matt Martin and Aidan Tarrant

BILOXI – On Feb. 1, Memorial Health System officially took over Merit Health Biloxi, solidifying its position as the dominant healthcare provider in the region. According to Fitch Ratings, Memorial now controls more than 85% of the local health care market.

This isn’t Memorial’s first hospital acquisition. In 2019, it took over Stone County Hospital and expanded services. Memorial considers that transition a success and expects similar results in Biloxi.

However, health care experts caution that when one provider dominates a market, it can lead to higher prices and fewer options for patients.

Expanding specialty care and services

Kristian Spear, Hospital Administrator at Memorial Hospital Biloxi, speaks on the hospital’s acquisition and future goals for improvement. (RHCJC News)

One of the biggest benefits of the acquisition, according to Kristian Spear, the new administrator of Memorial Hospital Biloxi, will be access to Memorial’s referral network.

By joining Memorial’s network, Biloxi patients will have access to more services, over 40 specialties and over 100 clinics.

“Everything that you can get at Gulfport, you will have access to here through the referral system,” Spear said.

One of the first improvements will be the reopening of the Radiation Oncology Clinic at Cedar Lake, which previously shut down due to “availability shortages,” though hospital administration did not expand on what that entailed.

“In the next few months, the community will see a difference,” Spear said. “We’re going to bring resources here that they haven’t had.”

Beyond specialty care, Memorial is also expanding hospital services and increasing capacity. Angela Benda, director of quality and performance improvement at Memorial Hospital Biloxi, said the hospital is focused on growth.

“We’re a 153-bed hospital, and we average a census of right now about 30 to 40 a day. It’s not that much, and so, the plan is just to grow and give more services,” Benda said. “So, we’re going to expand on the fifth floor, open up more beds, more admissions, more surgeries, more provider presence, especially around the specialties like cardiology and OB-GYN and just a few others like that.”

For patient Kenneth Pritchett, a Biloxi resident for over 30 years, those changes couldn’t come soon enough.

Keneth Pritchett, a Biloxi resident for over 30 years, speaks on the introduction of new services at Memorial Hospital Biloxi. (RHCJC News) Credit: Larrison Campbell, Mississippi Today

Pritchett, who was diagnosed with congestive heart failure, received treatment at Merit Health Biloxi. He currently sees a cardiologist in Cedar Lake, a 15-minute drive on the interstate. He says having a cardiologist in Biloxi would make a difference.

“Yes, it’d be very helpful if it was closer,” Pritchett said. “That’d be right across the track instead of going on the interstate.”

Beyond specialty services and expanded capacity, Memorial is upgrading medical equipment and renovating the hospital to improve both function and appearance. As far as a timeline for these changes, Memorial said, “We are taking time to assess the needs and will make adjustments that make sense for patient care and employee workflow as time and budget allow.”

Unanswered questions: insurance and staffing

As Memorial Health System takes over Merit Health Biloxi, two major questions remain:

  1. Will patients still be covered under the same insurance plans?
  2. Will current hospital staff keep their jobs?

Insurance Concerns

Memorial has not finalized agreements with all insurance providers and has not provided a timeline for when those agreements will be in place.

In a statement, the hospital said:

“Memorial recommends that patients contact their insurance provider to get their specific coverage questions answered. However, patients should always seek to get the care they need, and Memorial will work through the financial process with the payers and the patients afterward.”

We asked Memorial Health System how the insurance agreements were handled after it acquired Stone County Hospital. They said they had “no additional input.”

What about hospital staff?

According to Spear, Merit Health Biloxi had around 500 employees.

“A lot of the employees here have worked here for many, many years. They’re very loyal. I want to continue that, and I want them to come to me when they have any concerns, questions, and I want to work with this team together,” Spear said.

She explained that there will be a 90-day transitional period where all employees are integrated into Memorial Health System’s software.

“Employees are not going to notice much of a difference. They’re still going to come to work. They’re going to do their day-to-day job. Over the next few months, we will probably do some transitioning of their computer system. But that’s not going to be right away.”

The transition to new ownership also means Memorial will evaluate how the hospital is operated and determine if changes need to be made.

“As we get it and assess the different workflows and the different policies, there will be some changes to that over time. Just it’s going to take time to get in here and figure that out.”

During this 90-day period, Erin Rosetti, Communications Manager at Memorial Health System said, “Biloxi employees in good standing will transition to Memorial at the same pay rate and equivalent job title.”

Kent Nicaud, President and CEO of Memorial Health System, said in a statement that the hospital is committed to “supporting our staff and ensuring they are aligned with the long-term vision of our health system.”

What research says about hospital consolidations

While Memorial is promising improvements, larger trends in hospital mergers raise important questions.

Research published by the Rand Corporation, a nonprofit, nonpartisan research organization, found that research into hospital consolidations reported increased prices anywhere from 3.9% to 65%, even among nonprofit hospitals.

Source: Liu, Jodi L., Zachary M. Levinson, Annetta Zhou, Xiaoxi Zhao, PhuongGiang Nguyen, and Nabeel Qureshi, Environmental Scan on Consolidation Trends and Impacts in Health Care Markets. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation, 2022.

The impact on patient care is mixed. Some studies suggest merging hospitals can streamline services and improve efficiency. Others indicate mergers reduce competition, which can drive up costs without necessarily improving care.

When asked about potential changes to the cost of care, hospital leaders declined to comment until after negations with insurance companies are finalized, but did clarify Memorial’s “prices are set.”

“We have a proven record of being able to go into institutions and transform them,” said Angie Juzang, Vice President of Marketing and Community Relations at Memorial Health System.

When Memorial acquired Stone County Hospital, it expanded the emergency room to provide 24/7 emergency room coverage and renovated the interior.

When asked whether prices increased after the Stone County acquisition, Memorial responded:

“Our presence has expanded access to health care for everyone in Stone County and the surrounding communities. We are providing quality healthcare, regardless of a patient’s ability to pay.”

The response did not directly address whether prices went up — leaving the question unanswered.

The bigger picture: Hospital consolidations on the rise

According to health care consulting firm Kaufman Hall, hospital mergers and acquisitions are returning to pre-pandemic levels and are expected to increase through 2025.

Hospitals are seeking stronger financial partnerships to help expand services and remain stable in an uncertain health care market.

Image Description

Source: Kaufman Hall M&A Review

Proponents of hospital consolidations argue mergers help hospitals operate more efficiently by:

  • Sharing resources.
  • Reducing overhead costs.
  • Negotiating better supply pricing.

However, opponents warn few competitors in a market can:

  • Reduce incentives to lower prices.
  • Slow wage increases for hospital staff.
  • Lessen the pressure to improve services.

Leemore Dafny, PhD, a professor at Harvard and former deputy director for health care and antitrust at the Federal Trade Commission’s Bureau of Economics, has studied hospital consolidations extensively.

In testimony before Congress, she warned: “When rivals merge, prices increase, and there’s scant evidence of improvements in the quality of care that patients receive. There is also a fair amount of evidence that quality of care decreases.”

Meanwhile, an American Hospital Association analysis found consolidations lead to a 3.3% reduction in annual operating expenses and a 3.7% reduction in revenue per patient.

This article first appeared on Mississippi Today and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

Continue Reading

Mississippi Today

Adopted people face barriers obtaining birth certificates. Some lawmakers point to murky opposition from judges

Published

on

mississippitoday.org – Michael Goldberg – 2025-02-21 10:00:00

When Judi Cox was 18, she began searching for her biological mother. Two weeks later she discovered her mother had already died. 

Cox, 41, was born in Gulfport. Her mother was 15 and her father didn’t know he had a child. He would discover his daughter’s existence only when, as an adult, she took an ancestry test and matched with his niece. 

It was this opaque family history, its details coming to light through a convergence of tragedy and happenstance, that led Cox to seek stronger legal protections for adopted people in Mississippi. Ensuring adopted people have access to their birth certificates has been a central pillar of her advocacy on behalf of adoptees. But legislative proposals to advance such protections have died for years, including this year.  

Cox said the failure is an example of discrimination against adopted people in Mississippi — where adoption has been championed as a reprieve for mothers forced into giving birth as a result of the state’s abortion ban. 

“A lot of people think it’s about search and reunion, and it’s not. It’s about having equal rights. I mean, everybody else has their birth certificate,” Cox said. “Why should we be denied ours?”

Mississippi lawmakers who have pushed unsuccessfully for legislation to guarantee adoptees access to their birth certificate have said, in private emails to Cox and interviews with Mississippi Today, that opposition comes from judges.

 “There are a few judges that oppose the bill from what I’ve heard,” wrote Republican Sen. Angela Hill in a 2023 email. 

Hill was recounting opposition to a bill that died during the 2023 legislative session, but a similar measure in 2025 met the same fate. In an interview this month, Hill said she believed the political opposition to the legislation could be bound up with personal interest.

“Somebody in a high place doesn’t want an adoption unsealed,” Hill said. “I don’t know who we’re protecting from somebody finding their birth parents,” Hill said. “But it leads you to believe some people have a very strong interest in keeping adoption records sealed. Unless it’s personal, I don’t understand it.”

In another 2023 email to Cox reviewed by Mississippi Today, Republican Rep. Lee Yancey wrote that some were concerned the bill “might be a deterrent to adoption if their identities were disclosed.”

The 2023 legislative session was the first time a proposal to guarantee adoptees access to their birth certificates was introduced under the state’s new legal landscape surrounding abortion.

In 2018, Mississippi enacted a law that banned most abortions after 15 weeks. The state’s only abortion clinic challenged the law, and that became the case that the U.S. Supreme Court used in 2022 to overturn Roe v. Wade, its landmark 1973 ruling that established a nationwide right to abortion.

Roe v. Wade had rested in part on a woman’s right to privacy, a legal framework Mississippi’s Solicitor General successfully undermined in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization. Before that ruling, anti-abortion advocates had feared allowing adoptees to obtain their birth certificates could push women toward abortion rather than adoption.

Abortion would look like a better option for parents who feared future contact or disclosure of their identities, the argument went. With legal access to abortion a thing of the past in Mississippi, Cox said she sees a contradiction.

“Mississippi does not recognize privacy in that matter, as far as abortions and all that. So if you don’t acknowledge it in an abortion setting, how can you do it in an adoption setting?” Cox said. “You can’t pick and choose whether you’re going to protect my privacy.”

Opponents to legislation easing access to birth certificates for adoptees have also argued that such proposals would unfairly override previous affidavits filed by birth parents requesting privacy.

The 2025 bill, proposed by Republican Rep. Billy Calvert, would direct the state Bureau of Vital Records to issue adoptees aged 21 and older a copy of their original birth certificate.

The bill would also have required the Bureau to prepare a form parents could use to indicate their preferences regarding contact from an adoptee. That provision, along with existing laws that guard against stalking, would give adoptees access to their birth certificate while protecting parents who don’t wish to be contacted, Cox said.

In 2021, Cox tried to get a copy of her birth certificate. She asked Lauderdale County Chancery Judge Charlie Smith, who is now retired, to unseal her adoption records. The Judge refused because Cox had already learned the identity of her biological parents, emails show.

“With the information that you already have, Judge Smith sees no reason to grant the request to open the sealed adoption records at this time,” wrote Tawanna Wright, administrator for the 12th District Chancery Court in Meridian. “If you would like to formally file a motion and request a hearing, you are certainly welcome to do so.”

In her case and others, judges often rely on a subjective definition of what constitutes a “good cause” for unsealing records, Cox said. Going through the current legal process for unsealing records can be costly, and adoptees can’t always control when and how they learn the identity of their biological parents, Cox added.

After Cox’s biological mother died, her biological uncle was going through her things and came across the phone number for Cox’s adoptive parents. He called them.

“My adoptive mom then called to tell me the news — just hours after learning I was expecting my first child,” Cox said.

This article first appeared on Mississippi Today and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

Continue Reading

Mississippi Today

Forty years after health official scaled fence in Jackson to save malnourished personal care home residents, unchecked horrors remain

Published

on

mississippitoday.org – Anna Wolfe – 2025-02-21 09:00:00

Neighbors could hear yelps from inside a 10-by-10-foot shed behind a house on Grand Avenue in west Jackson on an October afternoon in 1982.

The location was a known unlicensed personal care home — facilities meant to care for adults, often with mental illness, who cannot live on their own, but which have never been regulated by any state agency.

Local police said they couldn’t enter without a warrant and called Mendal Kemp, then-chief of licensing for the Mississippi State Care Commission, the precursor to the Mississippi State Department of Health.

Kemp arrived and, finding the property locked, borrowed a ladder from a neighbor and scaled an eight-foot wooden fence.

He made it past two vicious guard dogs, opened the storage room door and found eight severely emaciated individuals sitting on a cot and on the floor around the dark, unlit room. There was no running water or electricity, and the owner had given the residents a bucket to use as a bathroom. One had sores all over his back, another was completely blind. 

Kemp, his colleague from the Mississippi Department of Mental Health named Janne Patterson Swearengen and others spent four hours at the scene rescuing the individuals, who were transported to licensed facilities.

But the health officials were no strangers to these conditions. A few years earlier, the U.S. Supreme Court found state mental health hospitals could no longer hold nondangerous patients against their will, and thousands of patients from the nearby Mississippi State Hospital wound up in Jackson.

To answer, unlicensed personal care homes started cropping up, especially along West Capitol Street in large multi-story houses that had otherwise been abandoned, absent safety assurances like fire extinguishers or appropriate staffing.

“We couldn’t license them. So what do you do?” Kemp told Mississippi Today in a recent interview. “They couldn’t comply with any kind of standards. And these people were so helpless. They had been treated like dogs — ‘go lay down, stay in your room, don’t do this’ — and they’d been institutionalized for all this time, so they obeyed.”

Kemp’s office often received anonymous complaints about these facilities. His workers would go door to door and issue letters: get a license or close down.

“We’d go back, it’d be an empty house. She’d just moved down the street,” Kemp said.

The Grand Avenue discovery by Kemp and his colleagues made national news, resulted in the creation of the Coalition of Boarding Homes, and led to the passage of the Vulnerable Persons Act in 1986, which strengthened laws around protecting abused or neglected vulnerable adults.

READ MORE: In a city without a plan, anti-public sleeping bills pop up at Jackson City Hall and state Capitol

Forty years later, an underground network of unlicensed personal care homes in Jackson — and the horrors perpetuated against vulnerable residents living in some of them — persists.

In 2010, a woman living in an unlicensed personal care home in west Jackson died of hypothermia after being kept in a room with no heat and a broken window. In 2017, the health department raided three illegally-operating homes, finding that residents were living with no heat, toilets or bed linens, according to news reports. That home operator still has an active home health care business license. In 2021, three residents died after a man set fire to another unlicensed personal care home in north Jackson.

In January, Disability Rights Mississippi, a nonprofit and the state’s designated legal advocacy agency for people with disabilities, released a report detailing widespread misconduct in the industry of unlicensed personal care homes across Mississippi, where, unlike in other states, these facilities “have the ability to comfortably engage in illegal practices without the threat of licensing agencies penalizing them.”

State law requires that any home caring for more than four individuals not related to the homeowner be licensed by the Mississippi State Department of Health, adhering to a set of often costly safety requirements and inspections. Residents of these homes typically don’t need the level of care offered by a nursing home, but still need assistance to stay fed and bathed, take medicine, or get to and from appointments.

The health department licenses 11 of these homes in Jackson, according to an agency directory — down from 17 in 2017, according to the Clarion Ledger. The health department said in that time, smaller homes have been replaced with larger ones, so the reduction only accounts for a net loss of 15 beds.

Then there are unlicensed homes operating legally with fewer than four residents and those operating illegally with more than four residents – same as forty years ago. Disability Rights found that some owners try to skirt this rule, such as by placing residents in tents on their property, “to claim that only three people are ‘actually inside the house.’”

The Legislature saw a bill this session to get rid of this distinction, requiring homes with any patients to be licensed, but it quickly died. 

There’s no way of knowing for sure how many of these homes are operating under the radar, but Disability Rights estimates there could be two to three times as many unlicensed homes as licensed.

Individuals living in these facilities often have nowhere else to go. They sometimes sign over their monthly SSI checks, $900 of federal assistance for people with disabilities and often their only income, to the homeowner in exchange for paltry services and little to no allowance. Disability Rights found a home caring for six individuals pulling $4,800 per month in rent, far above the market value for the property, and it did not have a smoke detector or sprinkler system.

“Operating these homes does cost money, but the inconsistency and lack of oversight for ensuring residents are receiving adequate care and provisions, after handing over most or the entirety of their limited funds, creates a breeding ground for financial exploitation,” the Disability Rights report reads.

Aurora Baugh, who spent most of her career at the Department of Mental Health, retiring several years ago as the Coordinator of the Division of Recovery and Resiliency, said her agency long quit discharging folks from the mental hospitals to unlicensed personal care homes — but low housing stock is one of the sector’s largest challenges. The agencies that transition people from institutions to the community, like the Department of Mental Health, but also the Department of Corrections, have a stake in the conditions of these facilities.

“They’re the ones who make the difference if people go to licensed or unlicensed, but if you only have (11 in Jackson), what are you going to do? Put them in a hotel?” Baugh said.

And to make matters more complicated, some residents may prefer the lax rules offered in the unlicensed homes, such as the ability to come and go as they please or smoke cigarettes, as opposed to strict conditions in place at some licensed facilities or nursing homes.

“They wanted the freedom, you know, after being housed (in hospitals) for so many years,” Swearengen said.

In exchange, the Disability Rights report identified what residents inside some of these homes are enduring: plastic coverings or boarded up windows, deadbolted doors, no electricity, exposed wiring, bathrooms ill-equipped for disabled residents, no washer, dryer or stoves, locked food pantries and improper cooling and heating to the point where one resident’s body temperature decreased to 78 degrees. Disability Rights found residents that had not been bathed, wearing the same clothes for days, and residents receiving only one meal a day.

Typically, the conditions inside these facilities aren’t brought to light until an incident involving law enforcement occurs or someone makes a complaint, like in the case of Grand Avenue in 1982. 

But licensing officials aren’t exactly scaling fences today. 

Frances Fair, director of health facility licensure and certification at the Mississippi State Department of Health, said the department’s surveyors – “current day superheroes” – hit the streets every week in tough circumstances to examine conditions and investigate complaints inside the homes licensed by the department.

“But we do need to do it legally, within the framework of our authority,” Fair said, which does not include the same treatment for unlicensed homes.

When the health department receives word of a home operating illegally, Fair said it turns the information over to the Office of the Attorney General, whose responsibility she said it is to investigate.

Michelle Williams, chief of staff for Mississippi Attorney General Lynn Fitch, said the office has received at least 10 of these complaints from the health department since January of 2024, and that the office does investigate in these instances to determine if abuse, neglect of exploitation is occurring. But Williams also said a home simply operating without a license isn’t a crime, that the attorney general’s office doesn’t pursue licensure, and the health department should seek administrative relief in those cases.

The AG’s office investigates thousands of cases of alleged adult abuse, neglect or exploitation each year — most of which do not rise to the level of criminal prosecution — but Williams said the office does not capture data to show how many of those incidents occurred inside personal care homes, licensed or unlicensed.

In the gap, Disability Rights has taken the steps it can, filing civil court complaints to force illegal homes in Jackson to become licensed or close down: four in 2022 and one in 2024.

“Even when these homes are closed, there are no safeguards in place to prevent operators from reopening a new UPCH (unlicensed personal care home) in a different location, leaving residents vulnerable to continued exploitation and neglect,” reads the Disability Rights report.

Fair said solving the issue of predatory unlicensed personal care home owners will require stakeholders to “follow the money.” In the case of residents signing over their SSI checks to the personal care homes, the business owners become the official “representative payee” in the federal government’s records.

“As long as people can make money off of vulnerable adults and say they’re going to take care of somebody, but then they take their checks and commingle those funds with their own personal funds and there’s not a lot of oversight on that, then that can be a problem,” Fair said.

Fair said several agencies have a role to play, such as the U.S. Social Security Administration, which administers the funds ultimately going to these business owners and should be auditing to ensure residents are treated fairly.

The descriptions of the unlicensed homes found today in Mississippi — “inhumane living conditions”, “neglect by other residents and staff”, “unsafe, unsanitary, and uncaring” — mirror language from Kemp’s old papers.

“They were in deplorable conditions and in great need of attention,” Kemp wrote after the incident on Grand Avenue, according to an Oct. 20, 1982, Mississippi Health Care Commission memo obtained by Mississippi Today.

“Things must be a lot better,” Kemp mused during his interview with Mississippi Today.

“I don’t know that they’re better,” Swearengen, his former colleague, responded.

This article first appeared on Mississippi Today and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

Continue Reading

Trending