Kaiser Health News
As Low-Nicotine Cigarettes Hit the Market, Anti-Smoking Groups Press for Wider Standard
by Don Thompson
Fri, 30 Jun 2023 09:00:00 +0000
The idea seems simple enough.
Preserve all the rituals of smoking: Light up a cigarette, inhale the smoke, including the nasty stuff that can kill you, and exhale. But remove most of the nicotine, the chemical that makes tobacco so darn hard to quit, to help smokers smoke less.
The Food and Drug Administration has been contemplating that strategy for at least six years as one way to make it easier for smokers to cut back, if not quit entirely. Less than two years ago, it authorized 22nd Century Group, a publicly traded plant biotech company based in Buffalo, New York, to advertise its proprietary low-nicotine cigarettes as modified-risk tobacco products.
Now, the first authorized cigarettes with 95% less nicotine than traditional smokes are coming to California, Florida, and Texas in early July, after a year of test-marketing in Illinois and Colorado. It’s part of an aggressive rollout by 22nd Century that, by year’s end, could bring its products to 18 states โ markets that together account for more than half of U.S. cigarette sales.
But anti-smoking groups oppose greenlighting 22nd Century’s products. Instead, they urge federal regulators to expand on their original plan of setting a low-nicotine standard for all combustible cigarettes to make them minimally or nonaddictive. They expect the FDA to take the next step in that industrywide regulatory process as early as this fall.
“Unless and until there is a categorywide requirement that nicotine goes down to low, nonaddictive levels, this is not going to make a difference,” said Erika Sward, a spokesperson for the American Lung Association.
Major tobacco companies Altria, R.J. Reynolds, and ITG Brands did not respond to requests for comment.
Cigarette smoking is estimated to cause more than 480,000 deaths a year in the U.S., including from secondhand smoke, and contributes to tobacco use being the leading preventable cause of death nationally. In 2018, then-FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb wrote that setting a maximum nicotine level “could result in more than 8 million fewer tobacco-caused deaths through the end of the century – an undeniable public health benefit.”
The FDA reasoned that people would collectively smoke fewer cigarettes and have less exposure to the deadly toxins that are still present in low-nicotine cigarettes.
22nd Century says it used a patent-protected process to control nicotine biosynthesis in the tobacco plant, enabling it to create a pack of cigarettes with about as much nicotine as one Marlboro. It says generally that it uses “modern plant breeding technologies, including genetic engineering, gene-editing, and molecular breeding.”
Keeping 5% of the nicotine is enough to prevent smokers from seeking more to satisfy their craving, said John Miller, president of 22nd Century’s smoking division.
“There’s just enough in there that your brain thinks it’s getting it, but it’s not,” Miller said. “That was really one of the reasons we got to these levels of nicotine, is because you don’t have that additional smoking.”
Miller said the low-nicotine cigarettes can help some smokers cut back or quit, perhaps in conjunction with a nicotine patch or gum, when they’ve tried and failed with other stop-smoking programs.
Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids President Matthew L. Myers supports the development of an industrywide low-nicotine standard, saying the concept would work only if consumers no longer had the alternative of a higher-nicotine cigarette.
“The concern with a product that’s still addictive, but delivers low levels of nicotine, in fact is that consumers will smoke more, because the evidence shows that somebody who’s addicted will smoke enough to satisfy their craving,” Myers said.
Both the FDA and anti-smoking groups cited studies that found lower levels of nicotine don’t prompt smokers to smoke more to reach the same nicotine levels. But those studies assumed smokers wouldn’t have a high-nicotine alternative, anti-smoking groups and researchers said.
Allowing low-nicotine cigarettes while conventional cigarettes remain available may be a public health detriment if they discourage smokers from quitting entirely or encourage others to start smoking because they think there’s a safe way to experiment with cigarettes, the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids and several health associations wrote in a letter urging the FDA to reverse its 22nd Century decision.
22nd Century’s cigarettes are still dangerous, and consumers must substantially cut back or quit smoking to get health advantages. But anti-smoking groups fear many smokers won’t understand that.
“If people are looking at this as a magic bullet and are still continuing their tobacco use, they are not doing anything to change their risk,” said Sward, of the lung association.
Anti-smoking groups particularly object to allowing 22nd Century to market menthol cigarettes even as the FDA is considering outlawing such cigarettes nationwide.
FDA spokesperson Abby Capobianco confirmed that 22nd Century has the only FDA-authorized low-nicotine cigarette but did not respond to requests for comment on the FDA’s plans for regulating nicotine in cigarettes.
California already outlaws menthol flavoring, and Miller said the company won’t challenge that state’s ban and won’t sell its menthol cigarettes in California.
But Miller hopes the company will eventually win an exemption from any federal ban, in part, he said, because more than half of menthol smokers are likely to switch to conventional cigarettes.
“That’s not what the FDA wants to happen,” Miller said. “They need an offramp for these menthol smokers and ours is obviously the natural.”
The company is expanding into California, Florida, and Texas because of the nation-leading size of their smoking populations. It previously announced plans to also begin selling its very low-nicotine, or VLN, cigarettes this year in Arizona, New Mexico, and Utah, and it may move into 10 more states.
The company is prioritizing seven states that offer tax incentives for products the FDA has said reduce tobacco risk, believing its cigarettes will have a price advantage over others in Colorado, Connecticut, Kentucky, Michigan, North Carolina, New Mexico, and Utah. Miller said the company may lobby California lawmakers to add similar incentives as part of the state’s extensive efforts to discourage smoking, which still addicts 10% of its residents.
Miller declined to disclose the company’s market share from the two test states but said sales were above expectations.
“If we can get this to the level of, like, a nonalcoholic beer โ you know, 3% to 5% of the category โ it’s a game changer,” Miller said. “We know that there’s a latent demand in the market for this product.”
This article was produced by KFF Health News, which publishes California Healthline, an editorially independent service of the California Health Care Foundation.ย
By: Don Thompson
Title: As Low-Nicotine Cigarettes Hit the Market, Anti-Smoking Groups Press for Wider Standard
Sourced From: kffhealthnews.org/news/article/low-nicotine-cigarettes-fda-standard-addictive/
Published Date: Fri, 30 Jun 2023 09:00:00 +0000
Kaiser Health News
Election Outcome Could Bring Big Changes to Medicare
SUMMARY: During the campaign, both Donald Trump and Kamala Harris are positioning themselves as defenders of Medicare, each blaming the other for potential cuts to the program. The election could significantly impact Medicare’s future, especially with more beneficiaries opting for Medicare Advantage plans run by private insurers, a trend that could escalate under a Trump administration. Critics warn that increased privatization would limit care options and raise costs, while supporters argue these plans provide better benefits. Polls indicate that a candidate’s stance on Medicare heavily influences voter decisions, highlighting the program’s importance in the upcoming election.
The post Election Outcome Could Bring Big Changes to Medicare appeared first on kffhealthnews.org
Kaiser Health News
Whatโs at Stake: A Pivotal Election for Six Big Health Issues
SUMMARY: In the election campaign’s final days, Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump clash over health care, including issues of abortion access and the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Harris aims to preserve ACA subsidies and protect health care rights, while Trump’s campaign lacks clarity on health plans, suggesting significant cuts. The future of Medicaid, drug prices, and transgender health care also hinges on the election outcome. Trump’s proposals could roll back protections for these groups, contrasting with Harris’ promises to uphold existing health care rights and enhance drug pricing negotiations, setting stark differences for voters.
The post What’s at Stake: A Pivotal Election for Six Big Health Issues appeared first on kffhealthnews.org
Kaiser Health News
Trump quiere que Harris pague un precio polรญtico por ofrecer salud a inmigrantes sin papeles
SUMMARY: Marรญa Sรกnchez, una inmigrante de 87 aรฑos de Mรฉxico, vive sin papeles en Illinois y carecรญa de seguro mรฉdico durante aรฑos, a pesar de haber trabajado y pagado impuestos. A los 65, no pudo inscribirse en Medicare y evitรณ atenciรณn hasta caer enferma. En 2020, Illinois lanzรณ un programa que cubre a mayores indocumentados, permitiendo a Marรญa acceder a atenciรณn mรฉdica que le salvรณ la vida. Esta iniciativa se enmarca en un movimiento mรกs amplio en estados demรณcratas para proporcionar seguro a inmigrantes. Sin embargo, enfrenta crรญticas republicanas y desafรญos econรณmicos, dado el creciente costo del programa en Illinois.
The post Trump quiere que Harris pague un precio polรญtico por ofrecer salud a inmigrantes sin papeles appeared first on kffhealthnews.org
-
Kaiser Health News7 days ago
Vance Wrongly Blames Rural Hospital Closures on Immigrants in the Country Illegally
-
News from the South - Georgia News Feed6 days ago
Co-defendant takes plea deal in YSL RICO trial | FOX 5 News
-
Mississippi News Video6 days ago
Free Clinic of Meridian Celebrates 10 Years
-
News from the South - Arkansas News Feed6 days ago
Buc-eeโs set to open second Arkansas location
-
News from the South - North Carolina News Feed6 days ago
FBI arrests NC man known as 'AK Guru' who is accused of selling hundreds of machine guns
-
News from the South - Alabama News Feed3 days ago
“There is a man here trying to use your ID” Suspect caught in Elberta using stolen ID at victims wor
-
Mississippi News Video6 days ago
Macon enacts Halloween curfew
-
Mississippi News5 days ago
Lowndes Co. inmate sentenced to 32 years in state prison