Connect with us

Mississippi Today

Appeals court tosses ex-Jackson police detective’s manslaughter conviction

Published

on

Mississippi’s appeals court reversed the manslaughter conviction of a former Jackson police officer who pulled a man from his car and slammed him to the ground, citing insufficient evidence.

The ruling also rendered an acquittal.

“The State concedes error in this issue,” reads Tuesday’s majority opinion written by Chief Justice Donna Barnes of the Mississippi Court of Appeals. “After review, we likewise conclude that the evidence was insufficient to support the verdict.”

Justices Virginia Carlton, Jim Greenlee, Anthony Lawrence III and Joel Smith concurred and Justice Jack Wilson concurred in part. The remaining four justices dissented.

On Aug. 5, 2022, former detective Anthony Fox was found guilty of culpable-negligence manslaughter for the death of 62-year-old George Robinson. This came about two years after his indictment with two other officers for second degree murder. He received a 20-year prison sentence with 15 years suspended and five to serve, followed by five years probation.

In a Tuesday statement, Hinds County District Attorney Jody Owens II said he is disappointed in the court’s decision but is thankful for its careful consideration of the case.

“The Hinds County District Attorney’s Office’s goal in each case is to seek justice,” he said in the statement. “… While we carefully review the Court’s decision and evaluate the appropriate path forward, our thoughts and prayers are with the family of George Robinson.” 

The evening Jan. 13, 2019, Fox was searching for a suspect involved in the shooting death of a local pastor. Officers were in the area of Jones Avenue when they encountered Robinson, who was hosting a barbeque at his home to celebrate his recent recovery from a stroke.

Two people approached Robinson’s car to ask for change to buy food. Fox testified that he thought they were engaging in a drug sale. Officers asked Robinson to get out of the car, and the man told officers he couldn’t move very fast and was trying to take his seatbelt off, according to court records.

Fox opened the door, grabbed the man and threw him to the ground – hitting Robinson’s head and resulting in bleeding. Officers called an ambulance, but then canceled the request for service before a paramedic arrived, according to court records.

The officer cited Robinson for disobeying police commands and resisting arrest, and then let him go. Robinson drove to see his girlfriend and lay down on the bed, and she left him to go to the store.

About 15 minutes after she returned, Robinson started to shake and foam at the mouth, according to court records. An ambulance came and took him to the hospital where doctors found a brain bleed and performed surgery on his head.

Robinson died Jan. 15, 2019. The state medical examiner testified that his cause of death was a homicide from at least three blunt injuries to the head.

The Court of Appeals agreed with Fox’s argument that there was insufficient evidence for a culpable negligence verdict and that the Hinds County Circuit Court acted improperly when it didn’t instruct the jury about a defense of “accident and misfortune.”

Culpable negligence would need to be supported by evidence that the victim’s death was a foreseeable result of the defendant’s actions., the court wrote. Medical evidence did not support how eyewitnesses described what happened to Robinson, the court wrote, noting how medical experts testified that Robinson would have had more injuries.

Robinson’s medical history including a history of strokes, hypertension and blood thinner medication also make it difficult to pinpoint whether the injuries caused by Robinson were the sole contributor to his death, the court wrote.

Taken altogether, the Court of Appeals found the eyewitnesses’ testimonies not to be credible, so they can’t be the basis for Fox’s conviction.

“The evidence does not support a finding, beyond a reasonable doubt, that Fox should have known that Robinson’s death was a probable result that he should have reasonably anticipated,” the court wrote.

The ruling comes less than six months after the Mississippi Attorney General’s Office made a similar argument and asked the court to reverse Fox’s conviction, saying Fox could not have reasonably foreseen that Robinson would die from “an everyday effort to subdue a resisting, non-compliant suspect using traditional non-lethal means.”

In a Tuesday statement, Attorney General Lynn Fitch said a wrong has been righted and Fox received the acquittal he deserves. She reiterated her support for law enforcement.

In his dissent, Justice John Emfinger said there was legally sufficient evidence to support the verdict, and the court must question whether Fox’s actions against Robinson were reasonable, such as why he took him out of the car or allowed his head to hit the pavement.

“If Fox did not have a reasonable suspicion that Robinson was involved in illegal activity, he had no lawful right to remove him from his vehicle,” he wrote. “Thus, any force that he used would be unreasonable.”

Justices Latrice Westbook, Deborah McDonald and David Neil McCarty joined the opinion.

However, Emfinger wrote the jury wasn’t properly instructed in some respects. In that case, he would reverse the conviction and ask the court to hold a new trial with proper instructions.

In its statement, the Hinds County district attorney’s office said it followed the law and that the jurors were instructed on the law.

This article first appeared on Mississippi Today and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

Mississippi Today

See how much your Mississippi school district stands to lose in Trump’s federal funding freeze

Published

on

mississippitoday.org – @MSTODAYnews – 2025-04-17 15:57:00

Mississippi school districts are grappling with the fallout of the Trump administration’s decision to freeze roughly $137 million in federal money and are hoping the U.S. Department of Education will reverse the decision. 

Around 70 school districts were relying on the federal Department of Education’s decision under the Biden administration to allow them to spend federal pandemic grant money through next year. 

But new U.S. Secretary of Education Linda McMahon notified state and local officials last month that the Trump administration was immediately cutting off the money. 

Schools were already spending the money on a range of initiatives, including literacy and mathematics programs, mental health services, construction projects for outdated school facilities, and technology for rural districts.

“We’re really counting on all of our state and federal leaders to understand the predicament that we’re in as local school districts and do whatever it takes to get the federal government to honor this extension,” said Lawrence Hudson, the superintendent of Western Line School District in the Delta. 

Hudson told Mississippi Today that his school district had already utilized federal money to renovate the heating and air systems in three old buildings in the district — two former Army barracks and a double-wide trailer — which had inferior ventilation. 

The district also planned to use the money to improve ventilation in another building. However, it was unable to complete the project by the original deadline because it needed to take place during the summer break when the kids were not in the building. 

Now those plans have been disrupted. Hudson said the district will have to find other money to pay for the project. 

Lance Evans, the Mississippi Superintendent of Education, wrote a letter to McMahan saying the federal government failed to provide adequate notice that it would cut off access to money committed to schools during the COVID-19 pandemic, and the action has put school districts like Hudson’s in a bind. 

Madi Biedermann, deputy assistant secretary for communications for the federal education department, told Mississippi Today in a statement that the COVID-19 pandemic is over and “school districts can no longer claim they are spending their emergency pandemic funds on ‘COVID relief.’” 

“The Department will consider extensions on an individual project-specific basis where it can be demonstrated that funds are being used to directly mitigate the effects of COVID-19 on student learning,” Biedermann said. 

Jackson Public School District, one of the largest districts in the state, has approximately $4.5 million in encumbered funds at risk due to the federal government’s decision, according to Earl Burke, the district’s Chief Operations Officer.

Of that amount, JPS had $3.6 million allocated for critical construction projects and just under $1 million designated for instructional support. 

“That said, despite our best efforts, it is important to note that some construction projects may not be completed by the start of the school year due to this shift in funding availability,” Burke said. 

The funding crunch also comes on the heels of Mississippi legislators voting to end their 2025 session without setting an annual budget. 

Mississippi is one of the most federally dependent states in the nation, and the Trump administration, through its Department of Government Efficiency, has made slashing government spending one of its priorities. 

Lt. Gov. Delbert Hosemann has said in recent interviews that legislative leaders might consider assisting state agencies that have been affected by federal funding cuts.

Whatever decisions federal and state leaders make, smaller school districts that received the federal money will be impacted. 

The Benton County School District, located in rural northeast Mississippi, completed a heating and air conditioning project for one of its buildings, according to Superintendent Regina Biggers. The district paid for the project but was banking on the federal government reimbursing it around $166,000, something that may not now happen. 

“This was a tremendous amount of money for a district our size,” Biggers said. 

This article first appeared on Mississippi Today and is republished here under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Continue Reading

Mississippi Today

Crime lab sees increase in rape kits following new law

Published

on

Crime lab sees increase in rape kits following new law

mississippitoday.org – @MSTODAYnews – 2025-04-17 15:01:00

Twenty-seven percent more rape kits were sent to the state crime lab in 2024 than the year before in Mississippi.

The increase is thanks in part to a law passed in 2023 to streamline rape kit processing, which officials say resulted in more rape kits making it to the crime lab. However, because Mississippi has no complete rape kit inventory, it’s impossible to tell what impact it made on the backlog.  

While variation from year to year is normal, the crime lab has not seen an influx that large in previous years – likely signifying the legislation’s effect, explained Commissioner Sean Tindell of the Department of Public Safety. 

Mississippi Department of Public Safety Commissioner Sean Tindell at his office in Jackson, Miss., Tuesday, January 24, 2023.

But Tindell added that he could not say how many kits, if any, are still getting stalled along the way.

House Bill 485 mandated law enforcement pick up rape kits from hospitals within 24 hours of being contacted, and that they transport the kits to the forensic lab within seven calendar days. It also created a sexual assault task force, whose members designed a system for survivors to track their rape kit as it changes hands. 

The tracking system went into operation September 2024, Tindell said. Any rape victim who had a kit done after then can track the status of the kit by putting its serial number into the online system

The idea was that rape kits could would no longer sit indefinitely in hospital refrigerators or in the trunks of cop cars, and that survivors would be kept in the know – the way patients are for any other hospital procedure.

“They leave the hospital and they don’t know where their kit is, they never hear anything. Can you imagine getting a cancer test and nobody ever calls you back to tell you what it was? For months or years or ever?” asked Ilse Knecht, policy director at End the Backlog, an organization seeking justice for sexual assault survivors through policy work around rape kits. 

Forensic scientist Jenn Odom operates an automated DNA extraction instrument at the Mississippi Crime Laboratory in Pearl, Miss., on Wednesday, April 2, 2025. The system uses silica-coated magnetic particles to capture DNA, followed by a series of washing steps to purify it, processing up to 24 samples in about 17 minutes.

Backlogged rape kits have long been problem across the U.S. – one that first sparked public outcry in 1999 when it was discovered that New York City was sitting on 17,000 untested rape kits

“What happened later was that the mayor decided to test them all, which was a years-long process, and there were very important and interesting cases that came out of that,” explained Knecht. “And it started to catch on, the other states started to look at what they had. And we started to get a sense of what was going on across the country.”

The root of the problem isn’t as simple as underfunded crime labs or a lack of resources in law enforcement agencies, Knecht said. It’s also a matter of culture, with some kits never being tested because victims aren’t believed. 

“If they’re not the perfect victim, the case is going to be closed before it’s even opened.”

The Mississippi Prosecutors’ Association did not respond to a request for comment on whether the increase in submissions to the crime lab has led to an increase in prosecutions. 

Knecht, who has 25 years of experience working in this area, joined End the Backlog in 2015, when she helped develop the group’s policy directives. After collaborating with dozens of sexual assault survivors and various professionals handling rape kits, her team came up with six pillars intended to guide states toward policies to enact meaningful and feasible change.

Mississippi’s 2023 legislation led to the adoption of three of the six pillars End the Backlog recommends: mandating the timely testing of all new kits; implementing mechanisms for survivors to easily find out about the status of their kits; and creating a tracking system for victims. 

The other three pillars, which Mississippi does not have, are: implementing an annual statewide inventory of kits; mandating submission and testing of all backlogged kits; and allocating funding to submit, test and track kits.

The timeline the 2023 legislation imposed on law enforcement is more than reasonable, according to Ken Winter, executive director of the Mississippi Association of Chiefs of Police.

“It absolutely has not taken more staff or resources,” Winter said. “The only thing it’s taking is somebody paying attention to the process and making sure the evidence is handled in a timely manner – and they should be doing that anyways.”

Rep. Angela Cockerham, I-Magnolia, left, during a meeting of House Judiciary B Committee while committee member Jill Ford, R-Madison, listens, at the Capitol in Jackson, Miss., Tuesday, March 3, 2020. (AP Photo/Rogelio V. Solis)

House Bill 485 was a bipartisan effort led by Rep. Angela Cockerham, I-Magnolia, and co-authored by Reps. Dana McLean, R-Columbus; Jill Ford, R-Madison; and Otis Anthony, D-Indianola.

McLean said she believed the legislation was the first step to getting justice for sexual assault survivors. 

But she later became aware that some rape victims have trouble earlier in the process – getting a rape kit done in the first place. McLean fought to change that this past session, and successfully oversaw the passage of a bill requiring hospitals to stock and perform rape kits. 

What makes the problem still more complicated in Mississippi – and four other states – is that the state has not mandated an inventory of rape kits. There is no way to tell the extent of Mississippi’s backlog – or at what point in the process the kits are getting backlogged.

McLean said she hopes to make a mandatory statewide inventory her focus next legislative session. 

The issue is dimensional, said Knecht. But the message of the movement is simple: to tell survivors that what they did by receiving a rape kit mattered. 

“All of this was created to keep a promise to survivors,” Knecht said. “And to society because guess what – these kits represent dangerous people on the street. And when they’re not tested, we have 100 pages of stories of crimes that maybe could have been prevented if a rape kit had just been tested.”

This article first appeared on Mississippi Today and is republished here under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Continue Reading

Mississippi Today

1863: Charlotte Brown refused to leave whites-only streetcar

Published

on

1863: Charlotte Brown refused to leave whites-only streetcar

mississippitoday.org – @MSTODAYnews – 2025-04-17 07:00:00

April 17, 1863

As darkness fell on San Francisco, a young Black woman named Charlotte Brown walked a block from her home on Filbert Street and took a seat on the “whites-only” horse-drawn streetcar. 

She and her family had moved to California from Maryland, a part of the city’s burgeoning Black middle class. Her father, James E. Brown, was an anti-slavery crusader and was a partner in the Black newspaper, Mirror of the Times. 

When the conductor came to collect tickets, she handed him the ticket she had purchased, only for him to refuse to take it. 

“He replied that colored persons were not allowed to ride,” she later testified. “I told him I had been in the habit of riding ever since the cars had been running. I answered that I had a great ways to go and I was later than I ought to be.” 

The conductor asked her several times to leave. Each time she refused. When a white woman objected to her presence, the conductor grabbed her by the arm and forced her off the streetcar. She boarded twice more with the same result and sued. 

Two years later, a jury awarded her the huge sum in her day of $500 (streetcar tickets were just 5 cents), and a judge ruled that barring passengers on the basis of race was illegal. He wrote in his ruling that he had no desire to “perpetuate a relic of barbarism.” 

Her victories paved the way for the official end of racial discrimination on streetcars in San Francisco and beyond.

This article first appeared on Mississippi Today and is republished here under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Continue Reading

Trending